For the fs industry, an eu ftt is unwelcome, placing significant. Automated trading in financial markets could be affected by a taxinduced increase in transaction costs, so that these costs would erode the marginal profit. House of lords european union committee call for evidence. Oxera what would be the economic impact of the proposed financial transaction tax on the eu.
This would be totally unjustified in light of the reputation that ucits has acquired as a model of excellence in the long term savings market. Assessment of the impact of an ftt on the real economy. This was accompanied by an impact assessment and other documentation. Annex 3 the impact of the ftt on eu11 financial markets. The ommissions impact assessment of the ftt fails to take this into account and relies on unsubstantiated assumptions about how revenue from ftt would be used. Trading venues, thomson reuters, bofaml analysis, oliver wyman. There are proposals of financial transaction tax, financial activity tax and different bank taxes. The latest information on the eu s ftt proposal and various country ftts. This report assesses the impact of the proposed eu financial transaction tax ftt. Financial transaction tax kpmg global kpmg international. Impact of the ftt on the profitability of financial market. The european union financial transaction tax eu ftt is a proposal made by the european.
Direct cost of the ftt the financial transactions tax ftt proposed by the european commission will be applied to the value of the sales and redemptions of ucits sharesunits as well as to the ucits portfolio transactions. The real economic impact of a european financial transactions tax. Pin, and 4 an approach where appeals are heard by the first tier tribunal ftt. Assessing potential eu fft collection models from self assessment to a central collection functionality self assessment involves liable parties to report chargeable transactions and remit any ftt due to the relevant tax authorities a centralized collection functionality generally involves a icsd or a new utility collecting the ftt on behalf of its membersparticipants who may be acting for. The impact assessment shows that the ftt will impact market behaviour and business models within the financial sector. Now undertake an impact assessment to identify how the eu ftt will affect your business and your business strategy. European commission, 20 this is a summary of the impact impact assessment regarding the financial transaction tax that the commisson has proposed to introduce within 11 states of the european union.
On 28 september the european commission published a draft directive on a common system of financial transaction tax ftt. The proposed eu ftt impact on the foreign exchange markets executive summary the foreign exchange fx market underpins international commerce and investment by allowing governments, businesses, investors and individuals to convert one currency to another. A roundup of ftt developments across europe following on from our previous newsletter, the enhanced cooperation procedure ecp to implement an eu ftt was today approved by the eu council the council in a major step forward for the eu ftt. An overview of the proposed eu financial transaction tax pdf 445 kb.
In a recent research report goldman sachs tried to assess the impact of the ftt proposal of the european commission. Analysis of impacts of different variants of a ftt according design. Those comments are cast around the directives objectives as stated in the proposal and its preceding impact assessment. Pdf assessing the impact of an eu financial transactions tax on. Directive 20087 eu hereafter eu impact assessment 2 european commission proposals for a council directive on a common system of financial transaction tax and amending directive 20087ec hereafter ec proposal 3 eu impact assessment the commission proposed a financial transaction tax ftt of 0. Thoughts on tax rates and revenue potential for financial transaction tax in u. The eu ets is one of the cornerstones of the uk framework to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and thus help. Impact of the ftt on the profitability of financial market activities the assessment of goldman sachs research. The proposed tax is to have a broad base, including most financial transactions equities, bonds, derivatives, both market traded and overthecounter. Eu ftt in participating member states on 1 january 2014. The last financial crisis, the role of financial institution in this process and the big scale of public aid to the financial institutions generate many ideas of introduction of new additional tax on financial institutions. A significant danger, however, is to confuse impact assessment and evaluation. Probably, the majority of impact assessments can contribute to addressing broader evaluation questions, and in many evaluation designs impact assessment is used together with other evaluative techniques in order to reach conclusions.
Investors are harmed by an ftt directly when they buy and sell, indirectly through trading at inferior prices, and indirectly through the impact on the economy. This document does not constitute in itself an impact assessment and it. The main objective of this qualitative research paper is to consider the extent to which the ftt is compatible with a number of significant financial sector regulatory initiatives based on evidence combining existing research, impact assessments and. The uk leaves the eu without an agreement either on 29 march 2019 or after the transitional period on 31 december 2020 section 2. The european union financial transaction tax eu ftt is a proposal made by the european commission to introduce a financial transaction tax ftt within some of the member states of the european union eu the proposed eu financial transaction tax would be separate from a bank levy, or a resolution levy, which some governments are proposing to impose on banks to insure them against the. The views expressed in this report are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the.
Commission to carry out an impact assessment of a ftt exploring its. Gender impact assessment can be employed in three ways. The introduction of the eu financial transaction tax ftt has been largely debated since the. We include in this judgment both the proposal for the eu ftt as well as the harkindefazio proposal for the u. The purpose of the agreement seems to be only political. Potential impact of the ftt on the ucits industry 1. Recently, the european commission has launched the idea of a financial transaction tax ftt. Eu ftt proposal 10071905 financial transactions to be. Are structural changes required to legal entity, booking model, etc what is the impact of the eu ftt on competitors e. Response on eu proposal for a financial transaction tax. In support of its eu wide ftt proposal, the european commission recently announced it is revising its initial impact assessment.
This is part of the needs analysis and planning activity of the policy cycle. However, as the european commissions own impact assessment acknowledges. However, the estimated negative impact on gdp estimated at 0. Text of the proposal enhanced cooperation pdf 142 kb 14 february 20 impact assessment enhanced cooperation 14 february 20. The ec proposal includes two antiavoidance principles one based on residence a transaction is taxable if at least one of the parties resides in one of the 11 participating eu member states and another based on. An overview of the proposed eu financial transaction tax pdf 445 kb official documentation.
Impact assessment ia is a key tool in this respect. The financial transaction tax ftt is now a widely discussed policy option that. Irish congress of trade unions the case for a financial. Meanwhile, discussions continue at an eu level about an eu ftt. Oct 04, 2011 on 28 september the european commission published a draft directive on a common system of financial transaction tax ftt. When applied addon, it is compatible with other ias e. An ftt can be imposed with varying effects depending upon how many other governments do so at the same time. Eu ftt proposal 10071905 financial transactions to be determined in autumn to be determined in autumn eu budget financial taxes in european counties source. The impact assessment foreseen in the teg mandate covers the economic, environmental dimensions and, notably, the financial dimension. Introduction the decision to develop a policy can be driven by many reasons. Commission staff working document impact assessment accompanying the document. Page 14 section 6bbva assessment of proposed eu11 ftt.
The draft sets out the main features of the ftt as proposed, including minimum tax rates. Ideally however, such a decision should be based in every case on sound analysis fed by the best data available. Spanish ftt which, on the surface, has similarities to the french ftt model. The latest information on the eus ftt proposal and various country. It became clear throughout 2012 that there was not unanimous support for the ftt and, as unanimity is required for the introduction of fiscal measures in the eu, it was not possible for an euwide ftt to be introduced. Assessment of the impact of an ftt on the relative attractiveness of transparent, regulated and multilateral trading venues in europe. French and german governments openly called for an eu wide ftt. Trade sustainability impact assessment in support of fta. Taxation of the financial sector taxation and customs union.
The revised assessment concludes that a ftt would have a positive impact on eu gdp growth contrary to the initial assessment which concluded that impact on gdp growth would be negative. The main ideas and assessment of financial transaction tax. Commission to carry out an impact assessment of a ftt exploring its advantages and drawbacks. The es impact assessment of the ftt estimated that the tax would have a significant effect on the derivatives market, reducing trading volume by between 70% and 90% e,20b. Commission, imf and ecb with respect to the potential impact of the introduction of this. Not transposing the directive would put the uk in breach of eu law and would also cause significant uncertainty for businesses who have already invested in preparation for the next phase of the ets. A cascade effect threatens to increase the tax burden. The analysis is based on transparent data sources, methodologies supported by existing studies, and a series of interviews with. Trade sustainability impact assessment in support of fta negotiations between the european union and australia final inception report 10th of may 2019 personal data in this document have been redacted according to the general data. Pdf environmental impact assessment for climate change. Procedural issues and consultation of interested parties as required by the impact assessment guidelines, this impact assessment has benefited from the consultation of all interested parties. Impact assessments examine whether there is a need for eu action and analyse the possible impacts of available solutions. Further, it asked to assess the potential of ftt options to contribute to the eu budget and to be used as innovative financing mechanisms to provide support for adaptation to and mitigation of climate change for developing. Studies highlighting the damaging impacts of a financial.
A purely eu ftt would see much trading leaving the eu, as happened to sweden when it unilaterally imposed such a tax in the 1980s and 90s. This report assesses the impact of the proposed eu financial transactiontax ftt on endusers. The full impact assessment is listed above this report. European union financial transaction tax wikipedia. An official study by the european commission suggests a flat 0. The project consists of two complementary components of equal importance. Sustainability impact assessment sia small and medium sized enterprises smes trade in services agreement tisa team leader tl terms of reference tor transpacific partnership tpp trade sustainability impact assessment trade sia ttip eu us transatlantic trade and investment partnership unctad. A european financial transaction tax copenhagen economics. To the extent that it is possible, constructively engage with governments. Memo from kpmgs eu tax centre pdf 70 kb eu ftt under enhanced cooperation.
Implications of a financial transactions tax for the. There is strong evidence including in the ec impact assessment that the. Taxation of the financial sector eu countries and their citizens want the financial sector pays its fair share of taxes. Eu withdrawal impact assessment executive summary the treasury select committee requested the fca to assess the impact of the uks exit from the eu across three areas. Response on eu proposal for a financial transaction tax john. The impact on sovereign bonds is particularly important given the debt problems facing several of the. The european union financial transaction tax eu ftt is a proposal made by the european commission to introduce a financial transaction tax ftt within some of the member states of the european union eu. Pdf under the context of emu debt and financial crisis, we assess the impact of emus announcement of a financial transactions tax ftt. Methodology for impact assessment of free trade agreements.
Impact assessment unit to check which legislative proposals will be accompanied by impact assessments. Review of impact assessments, swedish national debt office 2011 european commission proposal for a. If adopted, the eu ftt would have come into effect on 1 january 2014. An ecofin impact assessment was also confirmed and despite being silent on timing is expected at the beginning of q3 20. The commissioner for taxes reminded his audience of the original september 2011 proposal. Impact of eu financial transaction tax on the asset. The baseline estimates from the commissions impact assessment of the proposed ftt suggest that a broadbased ftt could generate 59 billion 0. The commission stresses that the revenue estimates are subject to much uncertainty and are highly sensitive to. At the time of writing of the ecs first impact assessment, ten member states had. Environmental impact assessment for climate change policy with the simulationbased integrated assessment model e3me ftt genie.
That is why the eu countries tax administrations are looking at ways to tax the financial sector, for example by introducing bank levies and national financial transaction taxes. The application of the eu 11 ftt to sovereign bonds1 ever since the european commission published its proposal for a european financial transactions tax ftt in september 2011, a debate has been raging over its impact on financial markets. Ec impact assessment updated wont trading just shift to fttfree zones. Key messages international tourism has seen continued expansion, despite occasional shocks, demonstrating the sectors strength and resilience and benefiting all regions in the world. Further, it asked to assess the potential of ftt options to contribute to the eu budget and to be used as innovative financing mechanisms to provide support for adaptation to. Report on the proposed ftt directive key points the ebf herewith sets forth its comments on the commissions proposal for a financial transactions tax ftt, as elaborated by its financial sector tax working group fst wg. The use of the above mentioned eu administrative cooperation tool is. Promised to be included in this impact assessment is a. Eu financial transaction tax the tiny tax with global ramifications 4 commercial how are individual lines of business affected. However, as the european commissions own impact assessment acknowledges, derivatives transactions will be severely affected by the ftt and this will have a significant impact on the returns of ucits funds, and the ability of funds to manage risk through hedging. Impact assessment of the covid 19 outbreak on international tourism updated 05 march 2020. International tourism has only experienced declines. When a commission proposal is referred to a parliamentary committee, the unit checks whether it is duly accompanied by an impact assessment and provides a short summary and initial appraisal of the impact assessment in question. These are carried out during the preparation phase, before the commission finalises a proposal for a new law.
It involves doing a prospective analysis of what the impact of an intervention might be, so as to inform policymaking the policymakers equivalent of business planning. In addition, the commission has performed an impact assessment of such a tax. Ftt newsletter a roundup of ftt developments across europe. European union economists have estimated that a proposed eu ftt, similar to the ones proposed in.
603 682 1354 480 884 1486 841 754 1285 1023 92 760 1143 695 731 5 1380 14 542 11 401 1501 1330 705 1280 513 42 126 1377 1437 1361